WordPress Membership Plugin
Thanks for taking a look at it The Assurer. Last night I actually found the problem after I had already submitted this support request. In case others run into this type of issue in the future…
I am using Simple Membership Plugin to mange membership on my site. The site has a member directory that I want to keep private. The directory is being displayed by a plugin called Church Admin Plugin. I added “loggedin=true” as an option to the Church Admin Plugin shortcode and also protected the page with Simple Membership Plugin. I removed the “loggedin=true” option in the Church Admin Plugin but that still didn’t fix the issue. To finally resolve the issue I had to explicitly set the shortcode to “loggedin=false”.
One clarification, if I navigate directly to the login form the “join Us” option is visible. This only happens when you attempt to navigate directly to a protected page without logging in first.